"I wrote about my brother Allie's baseball mitt. He's dead now. You'd have liked him. He was terrifically intelligent. He was the nicest and he never got mad at anybody. People with red hair are supposed to get mad easily, but Allie never did, and he had very red hair. He watched me play golf behind a fence. That's the kind of red hair he had."
I chose this scene because I feel like Allie was the only thing in Holden's life that made him happy. It seems like he doesn't really like his parents much, and he thinks that D.B. is a prostitute. The way he talks about Allie makes it seem like they were best friend. Throughout this whole part, he didn't say one swear word. This I think was a sign of being genuine. It definately got the readers attention.
He wrote about his brother's baseball glove for Stradlater's composition. When Stradlater reads this, he gets furious, and Holden just kind of brushes it off. Salinger is trying to make the reader feel sorry for him. Stradlater calls it a "goddam baseball glove" and tells Holden that he always gets things "backasswards." Holden just told us about something that meant a lot to him, and Stradlater was a total a-hole about it.
I completely agree with everything. Holden is portrayed as a terrible person and there isn't much positive in the story so far. This is one of the few positives, and I think it can be overlooked. Holden obviously has a soft side to him, and I think Salinger is trying to get that point across. Allie may or may not have been Holden's only close friend he has ever had.
ReplyDeleteI agree with both of you. It seemed to me that Allie was the only person that Holden had ever been close with and trusted. I also agree with you brett that is shows the kinder, softer side of him. Overall, I really like this quote. Good Choice
ReplyDeleteI agree with all of you. Holden does only seem to be happy with a few things in this book. Allie is definetly one of them. I also noticed that when ever Holden is talking about something that he likes or really cares about he doesn't swear. I agree that Salinger is probably trying to make the reader feel bad for Holden.
ReplyDelete